I watched a myth busters video recently where he explains that sound travels faster through helium because it is less dense than air. Thus you get a higher voice.
Why is this the case when sound clearly travels faster through denser mediums?
This is true for any mechanical wave. This means that all else equal, the denser the medium the slower the wave. The reason sound travels faster in solids is because their elasticity (bulk modulus) is so much higher.
Also solids can transmit different waves at different speeds because they have multiple elastic modes (shear, compression, torsion, etc.) which have different moduli associated with them.
Dominoes are not a wave. They are not an interplay between a restoring force and inertia. Dominoes are a chain reaction which is an interplay between stored potential energy and activation energy. Therefor, this gif is a vulgar mnemonic at best, but I feel that as an analogy this will likely lead to misconceptions.
Could you use this to explain the difference between running at different speeds. Each domino being footsteps to show how much more energy is used for sprinting and how long strides are not as fast but use less energy to get the same distance.
TYPICAL MISCONCEPTION, common in grade-school: that liquid density and behavior is half-way between gas and solid.
Instead, liquid and solid are nearly identical. Gas is sparse in comparison. Sound in gas will crawl along like a snail, while sounds in liquid and solid race along nearly equally (solid wins the race of course.)
GLORY! I’m teaching waves in a few weeks. Flawless timing.
Awesome demonstration! Density is the key baby.
I watched a myth busters video recently where he explains that sound travels faster through helium because it is less dense than air. Thus you get a higher voice.
Why is this the case when sound clearly travels faster through denser mediums?
Now i want to eat some pizza. like common even the colors match domino’s brand
i needed an emberassingly long time to figure out that the key is the space between the dominoes…
[mp4 link](https://g.redditmedia.com/P2_3kdKUgv288Ftwm2HZBVFDHW9EPFXf16PEu2uUM0U.gif?fm=mp4&mp4-fragmented=false&s=8d328e8354c03770d76460921bb184e2)
—
This mp4 version is 91.24% smaller than the gif (255.25 KB vs 2.85 MB).
—
*Beep, I’m a bot.* [FAQ](https://np.reddit.com/r/anti_gif_bot/wiki/index) | [author](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose?to=MrWasdennnoch) | [source](https://github.com/wasdennnoch/reddit-anti-gif-bot) | v1.1.2
I thought it was faster in water due to the incompressibility of it?
Gas is barely trying. Smh -_-
[deleted]
Slowass gas.
speed = (elastic component/inertial component)^.5
This is true for any mechanical wave. This means that all else equal, the denser the medium the slower the wave. The reason sound travels faster in solids is because their elasticity (bulk modulus) is so much higher.
Also solids can transmit different waves at different speeds because they have multiple elastic modes (shear, compression, torsion, etc.) which have different moduli associated with them.
Dominoes are not a wave. They are not an interplay between a restoring force and inertia. Dominoes are a chain reaction which is an interplay between stored potential energy and activation energy. Therefor, this gif is a vulgar mnemonic at best, but I feel that as an analogy this will likely lead to misconceptions.
/u/mrpennywhistle
Is…is this apocryphal? Not the idea, but using dominoes to demonstrate it. /u/mrpennywhistle ?
not a good analogy in my opinion…
/u/mrpennywhistle
Great job! I will 100% be linking to your vids!
I’m not a science guy but couldn’t you do this with gravity and light too? And see what the effects would be.
Well that was fucking helpful
Like why wouldn’t you show the waves traveling through various densities of objects?
I know I’ve seen this elsewhere before.
Is this mostly a medical thing?
What about plasma
So simple!
Gas is pulling up the rear once again.
Could you use this to explain the difference between running at different speeds. Each domino being footsteps to show how much more energy is used for sprinting and how long strides are not as fast but use less energy to get the same distance.
Спасибо !
TYPICAL MISCONCEPTION, common in grade-school: that liquid density and behavior is half-way between gas and solid.
Instead, liquid and solid are nearly identical. Gas is sparse in comparison. Sound in gas will crawl along like a snail, while sounds in liquid and solid race along nearly equally (solid wins the race of course.)
[deleted]