When thinking about taxing sugar-sweetened drinks in Canada, policy-makers need to take a look at lessons gained from tobacco tax, particularly how tax might increase inequalities and preconception, argues an analysis in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal)
” Supporters of a tax on sugar-sweetened drinks fast to stress favorable elements of a tobacco tax; nevertheless, an extensive contrast analysis exposes other lessons about worsening of injustice and preconception, consisting of racial preconception, in already-marginalized populations,” composes Natalie Riediger, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, with Andrea Bombak, Central Michigan University, Mount Pleasant, Michigan.
The authors take a look at the concerns around tax of sugar-sweetened drinks through a social justice lens.
” Numerous public health policies can have unexpected effects for some groups and it is necessary to think about this when carrying out brand-new policies,” they compose.
Individuals of low socioeconomic status and Aboriginal populations in Canada take in more sugar-sweetened drinks than the basic population and have greater rates of weight problems and diabetes.
” For tax of sugar-sweetened drinks to be reliable as a step of population health, it should impact usage in these populations.”
The authors recommend that taxing just particular sugar-sweetened drinks, particularly sodas, might increase preconception around weight problems and more isolate marginalized individuals. Sweetened coffee beverages, which are generally consumed in locations where individuals of greater socioeconomic status live or work, are not being suggested for tax, regardless of their increasing usage.
” A sweetened drink tax intended just at routine sodas might bring classist and racist overtones that might worsen preconception directed at already-marginalized groups,” compose the authors. “Simply puts, financially advantaged individuals might continue to consume their frappuccino, untaxed, while less rich people are taxed for their soda pop, regardless of comparable extra sugar material.”
Taxing soda might likewise impact relations with Aboriginal individuals who survive on reserves where there are long-lasting water advisories due to the fact that of hazardous supply. Lots of people in these scenarios count on sodas for hydration.
The authors advise participation of Aboriginal individuals in establishing tax policies around sugar-sweetened drinks.
” Sugar-sweetened drinks as the brand-new tobacco: taking a look at a proposed tax policy through a Canadian social justice lens” is released March 19,2018 .
Podcast irreversible link: https://soundcloud.com/cmajpodcasts/170379- ana
Disclaimer: We can make errors too. Have a good day.